had a similar thing last week, had the tank emptied and the taps out for a good few months, the corks had dried out - petrol everywhere, managed to shove it out the shed at least, and changed the tap plungers with spare I keep in a jar of petrol.
If not immersed or at least in contact with petrol they dry out and shrink, a spare set of plungers with corks fitted don't cost much and if stored in petrol in a sealed jar will stay expanded (actually they will take a good push to get in, good practice would be to change them on a regular basis ( note to self - yes it would)
BTW while on the subject does anybody know the size and thred of the small screw that keeps the plunger in the tap