Not quite or necessarily identical unfortunately. Gear driven E3Ls are as likely to come off things like AMC, Norton twins etc as from magdynos (which are just mags with a dynamo piggy-backed on top of them and driven off the magneto's drive). The armature shaft on gear driven jobs is different as there are keyways for woodruff keys, a tapped and threaded hole for securing same with an axial setscrew, and no taper + external thread for the sprocket or pulley as used on As. Plus the bearing and oil seal retainer on the drive end varies quite a bit between marques and models. The bodies are interchangeable and the brushes end is pretty much universal subject to variations in end-cover used, but the spindles and drive end arrangements do vary, to the point of non-interchangeability. Beesa-type shafts are longer too - which is why you have the visible non-connect you mention steve. It's a pain . . .