If those new holders were boughtn new, don't fit and you are not a happy fella, don't just junk them. The supplier needs to be made aware that his reputation can be more than just tarnished by the poor quality and lack of redress if no refund is forthcoming. You've bought in good faith, he needs to get it sorted. Ebay, PayPal and Credit Card chargebacks all offer some buyer protection, make it work for you.
As a caution to others, a rough geographical location is all we need to avoid something similar. Somewhere some fat *astard is enjoying a champagne lifestyle off the backs of folks like us. Spoil his day, use every mean trick in the book to get your smile back.
Swarfy