Okay then…
Seems like my stupid “smart charger” is smarter than me…
I received the new battery, tried to charge it, or “kick start” it with three different chargers and it still came up “bad”.
Finally, I looking really closely at the charger display, and noticed a tiny little “icon” that said: 12v. I pushed the mode button a few times and sure enough, there was a 6v mode. I thought the charger was smart enough to detect was type of battery it was connected to and would set itself accordingly. Well, it quickly charged my battery to “full”, I then hooked up my original battery and shortly had that one fully charged too! I guess I have a spare now…