Trev.... I reckon you are correct and the seal first appears in the BA7 and BA10 series of crankcases in 1953. This BA Series remains unchanged until the end of Plunger Crankcase production. I have a BA10 driveside case dated 14/6/57, with a number just below 16000.
The A10 of 1950, together with the A7 of that year are both ZA series, continuing on the A10 until 1952. The A7 series changes to AA7 for 1951/52. There is no AA10 series.
In summary it appears the cases originally had a slinger or a seal, depending on the year. The slinger type had a scroll to start with, as on the earlier Longstroke A7, but evidence would indicate this was phased out in favour of a smooth drive sleeve, which was later used with the seal.
Adrian... BSA changed model years in the Summer Holiday Shutdown during the month of August, allowing them to present their updated range at the annual Motor Show, ready for the following Spring. This is why model year follows the actual date of manufacture are slightly different, roughly a 4- 6 month leeway.
Swarfy.